|Source: Capital Pixel|
My investment approach runs into a fundamental hurdle with these types of funds - they are typically very expensive. For example, Morningstar reports that CMICX has expenses of 2.23%, a load of 1%, and turnover of 111%! Yikes!
Not surprisingly, Mornningstar reports that CMICX achieved a return of 0.75% over the past 10 years versus 2.84% on the S&P 500 index.,- a huge give-up over this time frame.
In keeping with the "creative juices" theme of the past couple of posts, I suggested the client think of directly buying the stocks of the fund. This client, by the way, has the time to do this--which is, obviously, an important consideration. Partial duplication keeps the client in a values-investing mode and hopefully leads to better long-term performance by avoiding the high expenses.
To carry out this approach, the client was directed to Yahoo! Finance. There they can put in the ticker symbol (CMICX) and on the right side click "more fund holdings." This would get them to:
|Source: Yahoo Finance|
There obviously will be some difference between returns of the fund and the constructed portfolio a type of basis risk), but it will satisfy the socially responsible criteria and avoid some heavy long-run expenses.
In fairness to Calvert, they do work hard to manage these funds, screen the stocks on the basis of strict criteria, and have some that perform well over the long term. My perspective is to give my clients the best possible shot at a successful retirement.
As a final point, this approach can be used for any high-priced fund by those willing and able to take on the risks mentioned.
Disclosure: I do not own the funds mentioned here but do own some of the stocks listed. This post is for educational purposes only.
Those are crazy fees! Agreed, it is a good cause, but in the end, that's a very steep price to pay for the individual investor.ReplyDelete
I like your suggestion of creating your own SR fund!
Calvert is probably the most successful family of socially responsible funds, but those fees are a killer. I agree with Moneycone, better to create your own fund filled with socially responsible stocks.ReplyDelete
I agree with you and MC: those fees are extremely high! I really liked your solution though. That way he can have some fun, invest in line with his values, learn some, and avoid the high fees. Again, that wasn't a bad solution at all.ReplyDelete
well explained.. thanks for sharing your thoughts. Trikle TradeReplyDelete